As reported on PhysOrg The George Institute for Global Health has recently analysed some 23 studies conducted since 1975 to the present day on the effectiveness of motorcycle training in reducing accidents & published their findings in The Cochrane Library. The analysis showed that there is NO clear evidence worldwide for what type of mototcycle rider training is effective in reducing accidents.
Findings include that pre license training acts as a barrier to riders obtaining their licence, whilst post licence training provided no evidence on reducing accidents. In essence the level of factual evidence rather than conjecture used in order to assess how effective rider training is was so poor that they were unable to ascertain what type of training (if any) is best.
What all the studies seem to have neglected to factor into the equation is the fact that all riders are individuals. How come there are riders who have been riding for over 20 years with no training without having had an accident whilst there are riders who get killed within a year of undergoing training?
Simple really, it’s a question of the riders psyche. The risk averse versus the risk prone. Those who are risk averse will naturally ride slower, more defensively and more cautiously. Those who are risk prone will be the opposite – they will ride faster, more aggressively and tend to throw caution to the wind.
In my opinion what is missing from the study is whether or not training will improve your skills – in other words make you a more competent rider, not whether training will make you less prone to having an accident. If you as a rider are willing to take the risk of overtaking a vehicle on a blind rise whilst travelling at twice the vehicles speed no amount of training will stop this. It is a risk factor, one you have evaluated & elected to ignore the inherent risks involved. Education through training will have taught you that this is dangerous, and could result in an accident (in fact common sense should tell you this), however if your personal risk profile is such that you ignore this then no amount of training of any sort will teach you not to do this. Likewise no amount of training will prevent the accident.
I am a strong advocate of training, continual training, with regular refresher courses & advise my students to do the same. However I often find students attending courses because “it’s the right thing to do” – peer pressure has coerced them into undergoing training, far more so than a genuine willingness to improve their skills. Yes, these people do learn things on the course, however within a week they are back to their old habits again & 99% of the training is forgotten. These are the sort of people who will never practice what they have been trained to do, simply because their risk profile is such that they see no merit in doing so, they will continue to ride recklessly and will eventually have an accident.
What’s even more ludicrous is the term “accidents” – this implies the event was unpredictable and unavoidable. Yet in reality the truth is that many are not accidents, they are events caused by poor risk assessment. How many times have we all been hanging around with a bunch of mates who ride & the general tone of the conversation is how close one rider came to an “accident” – invariably it is always the same couple of riders who are the topic of discussion, & when the “accident” invariably occurs the remainder of the riders all agree it was simply a matter of time. In other words they could see it coming. As traumatic as this is when it involves injury or even death the simple fact is that no amount of training will have prevented these, as safety is a state of mind, not a level of training achieved.
As riders we need zero analysis or studies conducted to be aware of the fact that from a safety perspective we are at a disadvantage when compared to cars, and no amount of training or skills improvement will change this. It is simple fact. To this end I will continue to advocate training as a method of skills improvement, for when training is applied to an individual who is in the lower risk profile bracket there will be a commensurate amount of safety increased through greater awareness by the rider and an improvement in defensive riding skills.
Take care and be safe whilst on your bikes.